You're reading 3 of 8 races free
Unlock the other 5 races on today's card, plus AI ratings on every runner and SmartBet ticket construction.
Presque Isle Downs Picks & Predictions — September 22, 2026
It's a wet Tuesday at Presque Isle Downs — rain is falling, temperatures are sitting at 64°F, and that dirt surface is going to tell a story all afternoon. Eight races on the card, and the weather is every bit as much a factor as the form lines. When the track gets wet at Presque Isle, pace scenarios shift, closers can get an extra gear, and horses with early mud experience suddenly become a lot more interesting.
We've got a mix of Maiden Special Weights, Claiming races, and a pair of Allowance spots to dig into — solid variety for a Tuesday card. Three races are fully open for everyone, and our premium breakdown covers the remaining five. Whether you're playing a few races for fun or building multi-race tickets, there's plenty to work with today.
Best Bets
Race 1
Maiden Special Weight · 1 mi · Dirt
A wide-open maiden sprint at a mile where TrackWiz ratings separate the field clearly — but with all zeroes in the win column, anything can happen when first-timers hit dirt for the first time.
Last Move opens at 8/1 on the morning line but carries the top TrackWiz rating in the field at 70.39 — a significant gap over the second-rated horse. Trainer Phil Schoenthal puts Antonio Gallardo in the irons, a pairing worth tracking on a horse that has flashed enough in the mornings to earn this kind of confidence. An avg speed figure of 52 isn't flashy, but in a maiden field where several runners have no published figure at all, any baseline is a leg up. At 8/1, if he hits the board you're getting paid — this is a legitimate overlay in our opinion.
Blessednotbothered checks in with a TrackWiz rating of 64.05, second-best in the field, and posts an avg speed of 53 under trainer M. Anthony Ferraro. The 9/2 morning line suggests the morning-line maker sees talent here, and with Martina Rojas handling the reins, this horse gets a pilot with plenty of local experience. In a maiden field loaded with question marks, a horse with any positive data point stands out.
Lucky Lucky Gingin draws the services of Israel Rodriguez for trainer Michael Trombetta — and Trombetta is a barn worth respecting when he ships a first-starter into a Maiden Special Weight. A TrackWiz rating of 56.67 with an avg speed of 55 puts this horse squarely in the competitive zone, and the 3/1 morning line is the shortest in the field. Use her underneath in exactas and trifectas as a dependable safety net.
Race 2
Claiming · 6 fur · Dirt
A claiming sprint that sets up as a two-horse battle between a clear TrackWiz standout and a surprisingly potent pace rival — but there's enough depth in this eight-horse field to produce a contentious finish.
Hightail Fox owns the top TrackWiz rating in the field at 87.08 — a wide margin over second-place Expresso Bay at 65.67. The avg speed of 56 ties for best in the field, and trainer Michael Pappada puts Rosario Montanez up, a strong local combination. A career win rate of 11% in a claiming field isn't alarming when the raw ability numbers are this dominant. Bet to win confidently at 3/1.
The Sinner Is You brings a 25% career win rate — second-best in the field — which speaks to a horse that fires when the conditions are right. Trainer Murray Rojas keeps it in the family with Martina Rojas riding, and that familiarity matters in short sprints where a clean break can be decisive. A TrackWiz rating of 72.77 is well clear of the mid-pack, making this a logical exacta partner with Hightail Fox.
Expresso Bay comes in with the second-highest TrackWiz rating at 65.67 and matches the field-best avg speed figure of 56, giving trainer Brandon Kulp and jockey Taylor Kingsley a live runner at a 5/2 morning line that implies the oddsmakers agree. A 14% career win rate in claiming company is respectable, and if the pace scenario sets up with speed on the front end burning each other out, Expresso Bay could be closing late into a piece of the prize.
Race 3
Maiden Special Weight · 6 fur · Dirt
Another first-time maiden field with tightly bunched ratings across the top four, where the pace scenario over six furlongs could matter just as much as raw talent.
Quinntopia tops the TrackWiz ratings at 57.50 and backs it up with an avg speed figure of 56 — the best in the field — under trainer Michael Pappada and jockey Rosario Montanez, a pairing that already surfaces as one of the sharpest at the meet. At 5/2 on the morning line, Quinntopia is the public's choice and our analysis agrees. In a field of maidens with spotty figures, having the top speed number is a meaningful edge.
Walker sits just a tick below Quinntopia in the ratings at 56.67 with a solid avg speed of 55, and trainer S. Matthew Kintz hands the mount to the in-form Gaddiel Martinez. The 3/1 morning line reflects legitimate confidence, and in a race where pace could be contested, Walker's profile suggests a horse capable of tracking and pouncing. A natural exacta partner with our top pick.
Flounder draws in at 4/1 for trainer Kevin Rice with jockey Ciera Pruitt in the saddle. The TrackWiz rating of 55 keeps Flounder right in the mix, and while there's no published avg speed figure, Rice is no stranger to developing young horses at Presque Isle. At 4/1, there's enough value to include in trifecta coverage as a live outsider who could grab a share.
Our three free races lead off the card and deserve a close look given the conditions. Last Move opens the day in a one-mile Maiden Special Weight — an 8/1 morning line price with a TrackWiz rating of 70.39 on a surface that could play to unexpected strengths. Maiden routes on an off track have a way of scrambling the field, which makes a price like that genuinely interesting. In Race 2, Hightail Fox tops our board in a 6-furlong Claimer with an 87.08 rating — one of the stronger numbers on today's full card — and that 3/1 morning line might actually represent fair value. Race 3 brings another Maiden Special Weight going 6 furlongs, where Quinntopia breaks from the gate at 5/2. The rating (57.5) reflects how wide open maiden dirt sprints can be, especially in the rain, so manage expectations and ticket size accordingly.
The throughline connecting these free picks: on a wet track, respect horses that have shown any comfort rating on off surfaces, lean toward those with cleaner trip histories, and don't dismiss the longer prices just because they're on the outside of the morning line.
Send me tomorrow's free Presque Isle Downs card before post time.
Free picks in your inbox each morning. No card required, unsubscribe anytime.
Full Card Analysis
Premium Content
Get the Full Card Analysis
Unlock expert picks for every race, detailed speed figures, trainer angles, and our SmartBet recommendations.
Bottom line: rain at Presque Isle means today's card rewards sharp handicapping over gut instinct. Last Move at 8/1 is our free-card longshot to watch, Hightail Fox looks like a confident spot play, and Starlit Sky headlines the premium side with the top rating on the card. Tread carefully in the maiden races, respect the off-track variable, and size your tickets accordingly. Full card analysis — pace, exotics, and all eight races — is waiting for subscribers.