Daily Picks

Presque Isle Downs Picks & Predictions — May 25, 2026

Monday, May 25, 20268 racesPresque Isle Downs

Happy Memorial Day from Presque Isle Downs, where a full 8-race card is on tap under partly cloudy skies and a comfortable 63°F. Conditions look ideal for fast times on the dirt — no rain in the picture, no excuse for the favorites to hide behind a sloppy track. Days like this tend to favor horses with clean form and honest pace figures, so we're leaning into the numbers hard today.

The card is a solid mix of maiden claimers, open claimers, and a Maiden Special Weight that should draw some lightly raced horses with upside. There's also a Starter Optional Claiming event in Race 7 that's worth watching closely for pace dynamics. Eight races, eight opinions — let's break it down.

Best Bets

Race 1

4:30 PM EDT

Maiden Claiming · 1 mi · Dirt

A maiden claiming mile where two horses stand clear on TrackWiz ratings — but the morning line favorite and our top pick are different horses, which sets up an interesting overlay situation at the windows.

win3Tiger Eye PearlML 5/2

Tiger Eye Pearl (No. 3) owns the field's top TrackWiz rating at 87.81 and edges out the rest with an avgSpeed figure of 53 — the best in this six-horse field. Trainer Juan Arriagada sends her out with Antonio Gallardo in the irons, a solid combination for a maiden at a mile. The 5/2 morning line is fair, but given the rating edge over even the ML favorite Starlit Sky, don't be surprised if the market tightens further at post time.

place6Starlit SkyML 2/1

Starlit Sky (No. 6) is the public's pick at 2/1 and carries a strong 79.11 rating, second only to our top choice. Trainer Linda Rice is a seasoned conditioner, and Israel Rodriguez is one of the more consistent jockeys on the Presque Isle circuit. She's a logical place horse if Tiger Eye Pearl gets the job done up front.

show5LillesandML 3/1

Lillesand (No. 5) rounds out the superfecta core with a 53.02 rating and a matching avgSpeed of 53 — tied for best in the field alongside Tiger Eye Pearl. The 3/1 morning line offers real value for a show position, and trainer Michael Pappada has a horse that figures to be in the mix around the first turn of this one-mile dirt maiden.

Race 2

4:57 PM EDT

Claiming · 5 1/2 fur · Dirt

Speed figures point to a two-horse battle at the top, but the pace scenario on a 5.5-furlong dash could spread the field — and there's legitimate value hiding behind the chalk.

win1Imposter SyndromeML 7/2

Imposter Syndrome (No. 1) leads all horses with the field's top avgSpeed figure of 56 and a strong TrackWiz rating of 85.76. Trainer S. Matthew Kintz puts Gaddiel Martinez in the saddle, and breaking from the rail in a sprint sets up a pace-stalking scenario that suits a horse with these raw numbers. The 7/2 morning line represents fair value given the edge in speed figures — this is a horse that could wire the field or sit just off a hot pace.

place3SnovemberML 5/1

Snovember (No. 3) has a 84.17 rating — just a hair behind our top pick — and Huber Villa-Gomez has been active around the Presque Isle grounds this meet. At 5/1, there's a real case that the market is underestimating a horse with the second-best rating in the race. Trainer Debbie Schaber knows this track well, and Snovember figures to be a strong exacta complement.

show4Pancho Slips AwayML 3/1

Pancho Slips Away (No. 4) shares that elite avgSpeed of 56 with Imposter Syndrome and rates third overall in the field at 69.84. Carlos Barbosa gives this Kevin Rice trainee a capable ride, and a 3/1 number on the morning line makes the show spot very playable — especially in trifectas underneath the top two rated horses.

Race 3

5:24 PM EDT

Claiming · 5 1/2 fur · Dirt

The morning line favorite doesn't match the TrackWiz model's top pick here, which is always an interesting tension — Ransom Money offers big-ticket value at 8/1 while Happy Instead gets all the public love at 2/1.

win5Ransom MoneyML 8/1

Ransom Money (No. 5) is the standout TrackWiz value play of this race — top rating in the field at 79.79 despite being posted at 8/1 on the morning line. The avgSpeed of 56 is the class of this field, and an 18% career win rate is solid for this level. Trainer Debbie Schaber and jockey Huber Villa-Gomez connect nicely, and if the public overlooks this horse in favor of the odds-on favorite, the overlay here could be significant.

place1Happy InsteadML 2/1

Happy Instead (No. 1) draws the most public attention at 2/1 and has earned it — a 20% career win rate is the best in this field, and trainer Juan Arriagada sends out Israel Rodriguez from the rail. The 64.26 rating trails Ransom Money by a solid margin on our model, but Happy Instead's consistency makes this a reliable place contender.

show4CondemnationML 8/1

Condemnation (No. 4) rates third in the field at 62.65 and offers a sneaky 8/1 morning line price for the show spot. Victor Severino rides for Michael Pappada, and an 11% career win rate tells you this horse knows how to compete. Condemnation is the kind of horse that can sneak into a trifecta payoff at a tasty price.

Our three free races set a nice early tone. Race 1 kicks things off over a full mile of dirt, where Tiger Eye Pearl (morning line 5/2) enters as our top-rated horse on the card with an 87.81 TrackWiz rating — the highest mark of the entire day. A 5/2 morning line for the best-rated horse on the card is exactly the kind of fair price we're happy to play. In Race 2, Imposter Syndrome (7/2) brings strong figures into a 5½-furlong sprint against claimers — watch for a front-running pace scenario that could leave rivals scrambling. Then in Race 3, don't sleep on Ransom Money at 8/1 morning line. A 79.79 rating in a field priced shorter across the board signals genuine value — this is the type of longshot angle that pays for your afternoon.

With all three free races on dirt and no weather concerns muddying the picture, our analysis leans toward horses with proven dirt form and consistent early fractions. Clean conditions mean the times will tell the truth today.

Full Card Analysis

Race 4

5:51 PM EDT

Claiming · 1 mi · Dirt

Our top-rated horse is buried at 8/1 in the morning line, creating one of the more compelling overlay situations on today's card — D'oro Lemon is a legitimate contender hiding in plain sight.

win7D'oro LemonML 8/1

D'oro Lemon (No. 7) paces the entire field with a TrackWiz rating of 79.79 — yet the morning line says 8/1. That kind of disconnect between our model and the public's perception is exactly what TrackWiz analysis is designed to identify. Trainer Katy Cheeks sends out Antonio Gallardo, and a 13% career win rate at this level is respectable. Over a mile of dirt, this rating edge should translate to a real chance at the front price.

place1MakoaML 7/2

Makoa (No. 1) is the second-rated horse in the field at 70.28 and figures to be forwardly placed from the inside post in a one-mile dirt race. A 9% career win rate is modest, but trainer Darien Rodriguez and jockey Edwin Gonzalez have the tools to put this horse in the right spot early. At 7/2, a place ticket on Makoa looks like a sensible safety net under the overlay.

show3RetekoML 5/2

Reteko (No. 3) rates third at 62.10 and matches Makoa's avgSpeed of 54 — the second-best in the field. The 5/2 morning line makes Reteko a public pick of sorts, and an 11% career win rate shows some experience getting to the line first. Trainer Scooter Davis and Rosario Montanez round out a workmanlike combination that could fill out trifectas at a reachable price.

Race 5

6:18 PM EDT

Maiden Special Weight · 5 1/2 fur · Dirt

A maiden special weight sprint without a dominant speed figure across the board — most of the field clusters closely in avgSpeed, making this a race where our top-rated horse's edge in the model stands out even more.

win3Spoken VowML 4/1

Spoken Vow (No. 3) is the clear pick here with the field's highest TrackWiz rating at 85.62 and the best avgSpeed figure at 55 — a full tick better than most of the field. Trainer Randall Russell puts Gaddiel Martinez aboard, and while this is a maiden field where anything can happen first time out, the data gap between Spoken Vow and the rest of the field is hard to ignore. The 4/1 morning line looks like legitimate value for the race's top-rated horse.

place5TwirlawayML 3/1

Twirlaway (No. 5) is the public's morning line choice at 3/1 and carries a 56.67 rating — respectable in this field. Trainer Scooter Davis and jockey Rosario Montanez are a familiar combo at Presque Isle, and while the avgSpeed of 52 trails Spoken Vow, the 3/1 chalk suggests connections are confident. A solid exacta underneath our top pick.

show4Out in the ColdML 7/2

Out in the Cold (No. 4) sits at 7/2 with a 55.83 rating and a 54 avgSpeed, nearly matching Spoken Vow's raw numbers. Trainer Timothy Hamm also has the top-rated Voodoo in this race, suggesting the barn has live runners competing against each other — worth noting when handicapping. Edwin Gonzalez gives this one a capable pilot, and the show spot at fair odds is a reasonable inclusion in trifectas.

Race 6

6:45 PM EDT

Claiming · 1 mi · Dirt

A nine-horse claiming field at a mile where three horses cluster tightly at the top of our ratings — the pace scenario will be key, and there's a legitimate favorite-beater hiding in the draw.

win2DiverML 4/1

Diver (No. 2) tops the field with a 85.62 TrackWiz rating and gets Edwin Gonzalez, one of the card's more active jockeys today, in the irons. Trainer Brandon Kulp sends this horse out at 4/1, which is fair for the top-rated horse in the race. A 9% career win rate is modest, but the rating suggests form cycles that the raw win number may undersell — in a field this tightly bunched, that rating edge matters.

place7Rachael's WagonML 6/1

Rachael's Wagon (No. 7) comes in with an 82.20 rating — nearly as strong as Diver — and trainer Paul McEntee has two horses entered in this race, which often signals the barn thinks it has a real shot with at least one. Israel Rodriguez handles the riding duties, and at 6/1 on the morning line, this is a horse that could easily flip the result with Diver. An excellent exacta wheel target.

show9Mr. ColossalML 3/1

Mr. Colossal (No. 9) holds a 79.41 rating and is posted at 3/1 — the public has noticed this one, and for good reason. Trainer Rory Barron sends out Gaddiel Martinez, and while a career win rate that reads zero is an eyebrow-raiser, the raw rating is the third-best in a competitive nine-horse field. Strong inclusion in trifecta tickets beneath the top two rated horses.

Race 7

7:12 PM EDT

Starter Optional Claiming · 6 fur · Dirt

A starter optional claiming sprint where career win percentages run high across the board — this is a field full of horses who know how to win, which makes pace scenario and current form the deciding factors.

win1Time for an AngelML 5/1

Time for an Angel (No. 1) leads the field on TrackWiz ratings at 84.17 and carries a 20% career win rate in a field full of accomplished runners. Trainer Scooter Davis and jockey Rosario Montanez team up from the rail, which in a six-furlong sprint can be a tricky spot to navigate — but this horse's numbers justify the confidence. The 5/1 morning line is the overlay in this spot given the top rating, and we think it's real value.

place2Mi AmoreML 4/1

Mi Amore (No. 2) has a 62.16 rating and a 22% career win rate — one of the better winning percentages in the field. Trainer Moises Valdez also has Fields of Green in the race, meaning this barn is double-barreled, and Walber Alencar gets the call on Mi Amore, suggesting it might be the barn's sharper entry. The 4/1 price is fair and this horse is a natural place play underneath our top pick.

show6No Tappin OutML 8/1

No Tappin Out (No. 6) is the show value angle at 8/1 with a 59.41 rating and — importantly — an avgSpeed of 56 that ties for the field's highest mark alongside Little Lamb Chop. Trainer Debbie Schaber has been consistent at this meet, and David Delgado knows how to navigate a sprint field. If the pace sets up favorably, No Tappin Out could sneak into the trifecta at a price that juices the payoff.

Race 8

7:39 PM EDT

Maiden Claiming · 5 1/2 fur · Dirt

A ten-horse maiden claiming field at 5.5 furlongs where three horses are clearly separated from the rest on our model — but the top-rated horse sits at only 7/2, meaning there are real place and show overlays deeper in the field.

win8IntimateML 7/2

Intimate (No. 8) tops this full field with a 86.35 TrackWiz rating — the highest mark of any horse in the race — and trainer W. John Bourke puts Walber Alencar in the irons. Despite a maiden record, the model numbers here are compelling, and at 7/2, the morning line acknowledges this is a contender. In a 5.5-furlong sprint, breaking from the 8-hole requires some early traffic management, but Alencar is an experienced hand at getting horses into position.

place5Gus's GalML 3/1

Gus's Gal (No. 5) is nearly the equal of Intimate on ratings — 78.78 to 86.35 — and is the public's morning line choice at 3/1. Trainer Linda Rice is one of the more accomplished conditioners in this field, and Israel Rodriguez gives this horse a strong pilot from a favorable post position. The pace scenario in a sprint often rewards the horse sitting just off the leader, and Gus's Gal has the numbers to do exactly that.

show9Starship DiscoveryML 8/1

Starship Discovery (No. 9) rounds out the top three on TrackWiz ratings at 78.38 and comes in at 8/1 on the morning line — that's a real price for a horse rated this close to the top two. Trainer Debbie Schaber is one of the busiest and most successful conditioners on today's card, and Huber Villa-Gomez gives this horse a capable ride. In trifecta play, Starship Discovery at 8/1 is exactly the kind of horse that turns a nice ticket into a great one.

Premium Content

Get the Full Card Analysis

Unlock expert picks for every race, detailed speed figures, trainer angles, and our SmartBet recommendations.

View Plans Sign In

Bottom line: Presque Isle delivers a clean, manageable 8-race card on a beautiful Memorial Day afternoon. Tiger Eye Pearl is our top-rated horse on the day and the clear headline free play. Ransom Money at 8/1 is the longshot angle worth a look in Race 3. And the premium races offer serious multi-race ticket potential for subscribers ready to go deep. Good luck at the windows — let's make Memorial Day a profitable one.

← Back to all picks

Best Bets

Race 1↗

Race 2↗

Race 3↗

Full Card Analysis

Get the Full Card Analysis

Race 1

Race 2

Race 3