Daily Picks

Horseshoe Indianapolis Picks & Predictions — September 21, 2026

September 21, 20269 racesAll Horseshoe Indianapolis picks

This card ran on September 21, 2026.

Best bets at Horseshoe Indianapolis, September 21, 2026

Race 16Mi PicaroML 2/12:10 PM EDT

Race 2 is free with an account, and the other 7 races are for members.

A free account opens race 2 too. Premium opens all 9, with AI ratings on every runner and SmartBet, which splits one bet across the horses you like.

Last 30 days at Horseshoe Indianapolis: our top pick won 22 of 112 races (20%) and finished in the money in 63.

Join Free See plans · from $9.99

We've got a full 9-race card at Horseshoe Indianapolis today, and the weather is playing ball — cloudy skies and a comfortable 68°F should keep conditions stable without any heat-related concerns for the horses or the turf course. Speaking of which, the grass gets a workout today with three turf routes on the card, so surface preferences are going to matter more than usual when you're building tickets.

The card leans heavily on shorter sprints and maiden events, which means we're dealing with some genuine unknown quantities — always fun, always dangerous. But that's also where value lives. TrackWiz analysis has flagged several horses with ratings north of 85 scattered across the afternoon, and a couple of morning-line overlays that deserve a serious look before post time.

Best Bets

Race 1

2:10 PM EDT

Maiden Special Weight · 5 1/2 fur · Dirt

A maiden sprint where one horse towers over the field on ratings, but a trio of runners bunched just below 56 on average speed makes the exacta interesting beneath the chalk.

win6Mi PicaroML 2/1

Mi Picaro enters as a massive standout on our TrackWiz ratings — an 88.54 dwarfs the next-best figure in the field by over 30 points. Jockey Santo Sanjur gets the call for trainer Antonio Duran, and the morning line of 2/1 reflects just how clearly the market respects this one. In a maiden field where no one has broken their maiden yet, that kind of rating separation in a 5 1/2-furlong dirt sprint is hard to fade.

place1Crazy LuckML 7/2

Crazy Luck draws the rail for trainer Genaro Garcia and posts a top-three average speed figure (53) in a field where the spread is narrow. A 55.83 TrackWiz rating puts Crazy Luck comfortably ahead of the middle pack, and at 7/2 on the morning line there's legitimate place value here if Mi Picaro handles all the chalk action.

show3Ephesian CatML 4/1

Ephesian Cat matches Crazy Luck's 53 average speed and sits within a single rating point of the place pick at 55.00, making this essentially a dead heat for second-tier credentials. Brian L. Hollingsworth rides for trainer Philip Coomer, and at 4/1 on the morning line, Ephesian Cat offers a solid show price that makes including this one in trifecta wheels a smart play.

Live odds, scratches and ratings for all 7 runners

Race 2: Free with an Account

Race 2

2:41 PM EDT

Allowance Optional Claiming · 5 1/2 fur · Dirt

Relentless Chick looks like the class of this allowance optional claiming field, but Spirited Anne at 7/2 offers real value and keeps this from being a single-horse affair.

win1Relentless ChickML 2/1

Relentless Chick is the standout here by nearly every measure — an 88.54 TrackWiz rating leads the field, and a 66% career win rate is exceptional for any horse at this level. Trainer Genaro Garcia has the connections dialed in, and jockey Amir Mendoza takes the mount in what figures to be a pace-pressing role on this 5 1/2-furlong dirt strip. At 2/1 morning line, this is the rare chalk that actually justifies its price.

place7Spirited AnneML 7/2

Spirited Anne is the logical alternative at 7/2 for trainer Larry Rivelli and jockey Walter A. Rodriguez, posting a 79.29 TrackWiz rating — second-best in the field by a clear margin. A 28% career win rate in an allowance optional claiming spot suggests this filly knows how to compete, and the rating gap between her and the third-best horse is substantial enough to project a place finish with confidence.

show8Unbridled DevineML 5/1

Unbridled Devine comes in with a 30% career win rate and a 55.53 TrackWiz rating, slotting in as third-best on our metrics. Fernando De La Cruz rides for trainer John Haran, and the 5/1 morning line makes Unbridled Devine worth anchoring in the show position of exacta and trifecta tickets — solid enough to hit the board without threatening the top two.

Live odds, scratches and ratings for all 9 runners

Today's three free races are all on the dirt and all come in at the 5½-furlong sprint distance — a nice, consistent sample to get your afternoon started. Mi Picaro opens the card as our top pick in Race 1 with an 88.54 TrackWiz rating against maiden special weight company, which is as strong a number as you'll see in a maiden opener. Relentless Chick carries that same 88.54 rating into Race 2's Allowance Optional Claiming — and at 2/1 on the morning line, she's worth your attention as a single or a key in your early exotics. Captain Shagaf is the shorter price in Race 3 at 8/5, but his 59 rating tells you the field is bunched and this race is more wide open than that morning line suggests — keep that in mind before automatically putting him on top of your tickets.

All three sprints on the same surface and same distance creates a rare opportunity to read the early bias quickly. If you're on-site or watching the early races closely, clock the first two and note where the winners are coming from — rail, middle, or outside — before you finalize your Race 3 approach. That track bias intel could be worth more than any single handicapping angle today.

Free with an account

Open the next race free

A free account opens the first 2 races at every track, and every race at our Track of the Day. No credit card needed.

Create a free account Sign in

Full Card Analysis

Race 3

3:12 PM EDT

Maiden Special Weight · 5 1/2 fur · Dirt

Captain Shagaf is the only horse in this maiden field with a meaningful speed figure on record, which shapes this sprint as a class-versus-unknown proposition.

win4Captain ShagafML 8/5

Captain Shagaf carries the lone meaningful average speed figure in this field at 54, paired with the top TrackWiz rating of 59.00 — and those numbers come with actual race experience behind them. The 8/5 morning line from trainer Genaro Garcia and jockey Amir Mendoza reflects market confidence in a horse that simply has more to work with than most of his rivals. In a maiden field this green, proven workout and speed figure data is a significant edge.

place7El AbeuloML 3/1

El Abeulo checks in at 56.67 on the TrackWiz scale — second-best in the field — and also brings a recorded 53 average speed, putting him in the minority of horses here with tangible form to evaluate. Joseph C. Bealmear rides for trainer John Haran at 3/1 on the morning line, and the rating edge over the rest of the pack makes El Abeulo the clearest logical backup to the favorite.

show5Heart CrusherML 5/1

Heart Crusher sits at 53.33 on our ratings, third-best in the field, though like most of this field the average speed is unrecorded — making this more of a projection play based on trainer Cipriano Contreras's prep work. Evin A. Roman rides at 5/1, which is a workable price for a show position in a wide-open maiden field where the top three are separated by meaningful gaps from the rest.

Live odds, scratches and ratings for all 7 runners

Race 4

3:43 PM EDT

Maiden Special Weight · 1 1/16 mi · Turf

This maiden turf route has a genuine three-horse battle at the top of the ratings, with the morning-line favorite failing to lead our metrics — creating real overlay potential.

win8Officer GambillML 7/2

Officer Gambill tops TrackWiz ratings at 86.35 despite carrying a 7/2 morning line, which means the market is underrating this horse relative to our analysis. Mitchell Murrill gets the mount for trainer Shawna Martin, and the 53 average speed is competitive in a field where the top three horses are clustered at 53-54. On a turf route of 1 1/16 miles, a horse with the highest rating and a patient jockey like Murrill is well-positioned to close ground late.

place5Cover ArtML 4/1

Cover Art is the most interesting number in the field — a 77.50 TrackWiz rating with the top average speed of 54 and a 4/1 morning line that doesn't reflect second-best status. Samuel E. Bermudez rides for trainer Jay J. Holden, who also saddles two other entrants in this race, suggesting a barn with multiple arrows in the quiver. If Holden's stable fires best, Cover Art is the one to beat.

show4Engine SolML 8/5

Engine Sol is the morning-line favorite at 8/5, but our ratings peg this horse third at 76.62 — a meaningful gap from the top two. Amir Mendoza rides for trainer Randy Matthews, and a 53 average speed is competitive enough to hit the board. The value play here is using Engine Sol underneath rather than on top, where the short price compresses your return without the ratings justifying top billing.

Live odds, scratches and ratings for all 8 runners

Race 5

4:14 PM EDT

Claiming · 5 1/2 fur · Dirt

El Payasito and Nothingbutjustice control the pace narrative in this claiming sprint, with a 25-point ratings gap separating the top two from a competitive but beatable mid-field.

win5El PayasitoML 9/2

El Payasito tops TrackWiz ratings at an 84.90 and posts a 54 average speed — not the fastest in the field but plenty competitive at 5 1/2 furlongs on dirt. Trainer Genaro Garcia sends out Amir Mendoza, a jockey with multiple mounts on today's card, and the 9/2 morning line represents real value for a horse our metrics have as the clear top selection. A 16% career win rate may look modest, but that number often understates horses who are peaking into their best form.

place2NothingbutjusticeML 8/5

Nothingbutjustice has the field's best average speed at 56 and a career win rate of 50% — that kind of conversion rate in a claiming field is genuinely impressive. Santo Sanjur rides for trainer Randy Matthews at 8/5, making this the morning-line favorite, but our analysis slots this horse second on overall ratings at 59.00. As a place play, the short price is fine given how consistently this horse has hit the board.

show3It's My SongML 4/1

It's My Song comes in at 58.69 on our ratings — essentially a dead heat with Nothingbutjustice on that measure — and Rodney A. Prescott rides for trainer Antonio Duran at 4/1. The 16% career win rate and 53 average speed won't set the world on fire, but in a field where the top three are clustered tightly, It's My Song is a logical show play in trifecta structures.

Live odds, scratches and ratings for all 8 runners

Race 6

4:45 PM EDT

Maiden Claiming · 1 mi · Turf

A full nine-horse maiden claiming turf mile with the win pick posting a higher TrackWiz rating than the morning-line favorite — classic overlay territory.

win5Positive EquityML 4/1

Positive Equity leads our ratings at 70.81 with Amir Mendoza up for trainer Genaro Garcia, and at 4/1 on the morning line this horse is being let into the pool at better value than the metrics suggest. The 53 average speed is mid-pack, but on a one-mile turf route where early pace can get honest, closers with strong overall ratings tend to run into big nights. Positive Equity is our top pick in a field where the morning-line favorite (Flatwater at 2/1) rates significantly lower on our model.

place7Night WatcherML 8/1

Night Watcher is a genuine longshot special here — posted at 8/1 on the morning line but carrying a 67.72 TrackWiz rating that's third-best in the field and backed by the top average speed (tied at 56) alongside Unionista. Marcelino Pedroza Jr. rides for trainer Emma Jimenez Sanchez, and if this one finds clear turf in the stretch, there's upside well beyond a place ticket.

show3Jr BartholomewML 4/1

Jr Bartholomew leads the field with a 63.67 TrackWiz rating and brings a 54 average speed to a race where the pace is unlikely to be blistering over a mile of turf. Joseph C. Bealmear rides for trainer Jose Cazares at 4/1, and this horse's rating edge over the bottom half of the field is significant enough to project a board finish with regularity in exotic tickets.

Live odds, scratches and ratings for all 9 runners

Race 7

5:16 PM EDT

Claiming · 6 fur · Dirt

Pickle Shoes is the clear ratings leader in this six-furlong claiming race, but Campaign Promises at 3/1 brings a 35% career win rate that commands respect in any field.

win1Pickle ShoesML 4/1

Pickle Shoes heads into this race with the field's top TrackWiz rating at 85.62, and the 25% career win rate at this level suggests a horse who knows how to close the deal. Evin A. Roman picks up the mount for trainer Tomas Medina, and at 4/1 there's genuine value given that our model has this horse atop the pile by more than six points over the next-best runner. A 55 average speed on a six-furlong dirt strip is right in the wheelhouse for this distance.

place5Campaign PromisesML 3/1

Campaign Promises is the horse we'd want underneath in every exotic — a 35% career win rate is the highest in the field and reflects a horse that competes deep into every race. Amir Mendoza rides for trainer Genaro Garcia at 3/1, and the 78.87 TrackWiz rating puts Campaign Promises clearly in the money picture. If the pace gets honest early, this one's closing kick should be enough to hold the place spot.

show8Don't Cross AlexisML 5/1

Don't Cross Alexis rounds out our top three with a 71.67 TrackWiz rating and a 30% career win rate — third-best in both categories in the field. Alexander Crispin rides for trainer Randy L. Klopp at 5/1, which is a comfortable price for a show play. This horse's combination of solid speed (54 average) and a winning pedigree makes a top-three finish a realistic expectation.

Live odds, scratches and ratings for all 8 runners

Race 8

5:47 PM EDT

Allowance · 5 fur · Turf

Joe the Tailor is the clear TrackWiz top selection in this five-furlong allowance turf sprint, but the real story is Slam Dunk Justice at 10/1 offering massive overlay value as our second-rated horse.

win5Joe the TailorML 7/2

Joe the Tailor has the goods to win this allowance turf sprint outright — an 85.28 TrackWiz rating leads the field, a 27% career win rate is strong at this level, and a top average speed figure of 56 projects well over five quick furlongs of turf. Orlando Mojica rides for trainer Armando Hernandez at 7/2, and the morning-line price reflects a market that agrees with our analysis. This is a confident top selection.

place9Slam Dunk JusticeML 10/1

Slam Dunk Justice is the value play of the night at 10/1 — our metrics have this horse second in the field at 76.88, nearly nine points ahead of the third-best runner. Marcelino Pedroza Jr. rides for trainer Genaro Garcia, a barn that has multiple live runners on today's card, and a 19% career win rate in allowance company is respectable. At double-digit odds for the second-best horse in the race on ratings, the place ticket here is a near must-play.

show3Illegal ContactML 9/2

Illegal Contact rates third on our model at 68.19 with a 31% career win rate — the highest conversion rate in the entire field. Irving Moncada rides for trainer Randy L. Klopp at 9/2, and a 55 average speed is competitive in this five-furlong turf sprint. The career win percentage alone makes this horse worth including in exacta and trifecta combinations as a legitimate threat to fill the show spot.

Live odds, scratches and ratings for all 9 runners

Race 9

6:15 PM EDT

Allowance · 350 yd · Dirt

A sprawling 11-horse quarter-horse allowance over 350 yards — Tw Trumps Secrets is the dominant ratings selection, but Streakindownthebeach at 5/2 brings the field's best win rate and makes the exacta a compelling ticket.

win2Tw Trumps SecretsML 2/1

Tw Trumps Secrets tops our TrackWiz ratings with an 88.54 — the highest figure among all horses in this race — and the 2/1 morning line reflects a horse the market genuinely respects. Diego Villamil Bocanegra rides for trainer Natasha Perez, and a 21% career win rate in quarter-horse company is right in line with competitive allowance runners at 350 yards. In a race this short, gate speed and raw ability dominate, and the ratings say this horse has both.

place7StreakindownthebeachML 5/2

Streakindownthebeach is the most dangerous horse in the field behind our top pick — a 74.97 TrackWiz rating paired with a 27% career win rate, the best conversion percentage among horses we're singling out in this race. Luis Eduardo Luna Diaz gets the mount for trainer Tim Eggleston at 5/2, and at that price relative to our second-best rating in the field, this is a legitimate place bet in its own right rather than just a backup.

show1This Is the OneML 7/2

This Is the One rounds out the top three at 65.84 on our ratings and carries a 15% career win rate for trainer Anthony F. Cunningham, who also saddles Gold Hearted Policy in this race. Luz Daniel Martinez rides at 7/2, and in a 350-yard sprint where fractions of a second separate the field, having the third-best rating in an 11-horse field is meaningful. Use this one in show and trifecta positions.

Live odds, scratches and ratings for all 11 runners

Premium Content

Get the Full Card Analysis

Unlock expert picks for every race, detailed speed figures, trainer angles, and our SmartBet recommendations.

View Plans Sign In

Bottom line: today's Horseshoe Indianapolis card is built for handicappers who do their homework. Mi Picaro and Relentless Chick are the two names to know from the free races, and the full-card premium analysis unlocks six more races worth playing — including some legitimate exotic opportunities on the turf. Grab the complete TrackWiz breakdown at /pricing and make sure you're set before the first post. Good luck today.

← All Horseshoe Indianapolis picks & predictions