Horseshoe Indianapolis Picks & Predictions — May 28, 2026
Happy Thursday at Horseshoe Indianapolis. We've got a nine-race card to work through this afternoon under partly cloudy skies and a comfortable 79°F — ideal conditions for a fast, sealed-up dirt surface. No weather excuses today; it's purely about the horses.
The card is a nice mix of claiming races, allowances, and maiden events spanning distances from a lightning-quick 300-yard quarter-horse dash all the way out to a mile and 70 yards. That variety means plenty of angles to attack, whether you're playing singles or building multi-race sequences. TrackWiz analysis has identified strong top picks across the full card, so let's get into it.
Best Bets
Race 1
Claiming · 5 1/2 fur · Dirt
A competitive 5½-furlong dirt claimer where two stablemates from trainer Genaro Garcia split the field, but the top TrackWiz ratings point to a clear 1-2 at the top that the market is slightly underestimating.
Dan's Candi Girl draws the rail and tops our ratings at 87.08, the highest mark in the field by a comfortable margin. Her average speed figure of 55 edges everyone else in here, giving her a measurable edge in raw ability over this claiming group. Trainer Gennadi Dorochenko puts Patrick Valenzuela in the irons — an experienced partnership that should have her ready to fire. At 3/1 on the morning line, this is a fair price for the top-rated horse in the race.
Zoomaha is the logical backup at 7/2, posting a TrackWiz rating of 83.32 — second-best in the field. A career win rate of 33% is the highest of any horse in this race, which tells you this horse knows how to get the job done when conditions align. Marcelino Pedroza, Jr. takes the mount, and with trainer Genaro Garcia sending out two horses today, the stable clearly has a live barn.
Castle Magic at 8/1 is worth a look in the exotics as the third-best-rated horse in the field at 65.10. A 25% career win rate gives her legitimate credentials at this level, and Mitchell Murrill is a capable hand who can find a good trip from post 2. If the top two beat each other up on the front end, Castle Magic could be sneaking into the frame.
Race 2
Claiming · 5 1/2 fur · Dirt
The morning-line favorite Ad Litteram faces a stiff challenge from B On the Loose, whose TrackWiz rating blows the field away — this could be a case where the public is wrong about the top of the market.
B On the Loose is the standout here with a field-best rating of 87.81, a full 19 points clear of the second-best horse. Trainer Jonathan Nance sends her out from post 6 with Rodney Prescott aboard at a generous 5/2 morning line. Her average speed figure of 54 matches the best in the race, and the TrackWiz model sees her as a clear class advantage over this field. If she runs anywhere near her top form, she should be controlling her own destiny.
Ad Litteram is the public's choice at 8/5 and rates second in our model at 68.41, but there's a notable gap between her and B On the Loose at the top. She's a solid place horse with Micah Meeks up for trainer Randy Klopp, who also saddles Gospel Music in this spot — a sign the barn is engaged. Her 14% career win rate is honest, and she'll likely be there at the wire for second money.
Gospel Music at 9/2 is the third-best-rated horse in the field at 64.90, just a tick behind Ad Litteram. Fernando De La Cruz takes the call, and trainer Randy Klopp having two horses in the same race can sometimes signal a complementary pace setup that benefits both runners. At near-double-digit odds, she's worth a small share in the trifecta.
Race 3
Allowance · 5 1/2 fur · Dirt
An allowance sprint that looks like a three-horse race on paper, with Cloudy Star, Unbridled Devine, and Catatonic clustered at the top of the ratings and the rest of the field well behind — but the pace picture could shuffle the order.
Cloudy Star is the class of the field according to TrackWiz, rating 88.40 at the top of the list. What stands out is the career win rate of 50% — this horse simply wins when it runs, and that kind of record in an allowance spot commands respect. Samuel Bermudez gets the ride for trainer Tomas Medina, and at 9/5, the public clearly agrees this is the one to beat. If her speed holds over this 5½-furlong trip, she's tough to knock off the top.
Unbridled Devine is a fascinating alternative at 4/1 with a rating of 85.62 — only 2.78 points behind Cloudy Star. A 35% career win rate is the second-highest in the field, and she's posting average speed figures of 55, tied for the best in the race. Alberto Burgos rides for trainer John Haran, who also has City Prayers in here, so the barn has options. At 4/1, she's a live underlay for exacta and trifecta plays.
Catatonic rounds out a logical top three at 5/2 with a rating of 81.75. Her average speed of 55 matches the top horses in this field, and Rodney Prescott — who picks up the mount for Larry Rivelli — is a savvy pilot who can place a horse well in a pace duel. She's not the most obvious winner, but at her morning line, she represents solid insurance in exacta and trifecta combinations.
The first three races on the card are fully unlocked for every TrackWiz reader. Race 1 kicks things off with Dan's Candi Girl at 3/1 on the morning line — a fair price for a horse our ratings peg at 87.08 in a claiming sprint. Race 2 brings B On the Loose (5/2, 87.81 rating) into a similar 5½-furlong dirt scenario, and our numbers actually like her slightly more than the crowd does right now. Then Race 3 steps up to an allowance condition where Cloudy Star opens as the 9/5 favorite — a deserved line given an 88.40 TrackWiz rating that leads this group. All three free races share the same 5½-furlong dirt trip, so if you're picking up on a speed or pace bias early in the card, it'll carry directly from one race to the next.
Full Card Analysis
Premium Content
Get the Full Card Analysis
Unlock expert picks for every race, detailed speed figures, trainer angles, and our SmartBet recommendations.
Today's best bets start with the free trio — Dan's Candi Girl, B On the Loose, and Cloudy Star — all in similar conditions early on the card. But the day's highest-rated horse, Socorro's Prayer, is locked in Race 5 premium coverage along with full exotic breakdowns across the back half of the card. If you want to play the full nine races with confidence, head to /pricing and get the complete TrackWiz analysis. Good luck at the windows.