Unlock the other 6 races on today's card, plus AI ratings on every runner and SmartBet ticket construction.

The winner is in our top 4 picks 75% of the time, across 17 tracks.

Daily Picks

Horseshoe Indianapolis Picks & Predictions — September 16, 2026

September 16, 20269 racesAll Horseshoe Indianapolis picks

We're heading to Horseshoe Indianapolis for a nine-race Wednesday card, and the conditions are about as cooperative as you could ask for in mid-September. Partly cloudy skies and 87°F means the dirt should be fast and consistent, which matters a lot when you're trying to project pace scenarios and figure out who benefits from a quick surface.

The card has a little bit of everything — claiming races, allowance spots, maiden fields, and a pair of turf routes that could get interesting if the grass is playing true. Three races are on the lawn today, so turf form is going to be just as important as dirt speed figures when you're building tickets.

TrackWiz has full analysis on all nine races. The first three are on the house — our free best bets give you a strong foundation for the card. The remaining six are available to subscribers, and today's premium coverage includes some genuinely intriguing spots with real overlay potential.

Best Bets

Race 1

6:10 PM EDT

Claiming · 1 mi · Dirt

The morning line favorite isn't the top-rated horse here — Concho's Prayer holds a commanding TrackWiz rating edge over the field in this one-mile claiming opener, setting up a potential mild upset of the odds board.

win6Concho's PrayerML 2/1

Concho's Prayer earns the highest TrackWiz rating in this field at 88.54, a meaningful gap above the 8/5 morning line chalk. Trainer Tim Eggleston already has two other horses in this race, suggesting he's targeting this spot with intention — and the 2/1 morning line indicates the connections have confidence. Fernando De La Cruz gets the call, and the one-mile dirt distance gives this horse room to settle and build into the race. The rating edge alone makes this the clear top choice.

place1Rosso FuocoML 8/5

Rosso Fuoco is the morning line favorite at 8/5 for a reason — a solid 76.27 rating and an average speed figure of 53 make this horse competitive at the mile. Jockey Joseph D. Ramos aboard a horse with a 10% career win rate may not sound flashy, but at this claiming level the consistency is what matters for a place ticket.

show2Indy KidML 8/1

Indy Kid at 8/1 looks like a fair price for a horse showing a 14% career win rate — the second-best win percentage in this field. Trainer Tim Eggleston's stable-mate dynamic is worth noting; if Concho's Prayer controls pace up front, Indy Kid may benefit from a ground-saving trip to hit the board.

Race 2

6:41 PM EDT

Allowance · 6 fur · Dirt

A compact six-furlong allowance sprint with four legitimate contenders bunched between 71 and 88 on TrackWiz ratings — the top end of this field is tightly contested, and pace could decide it.

win5Wosie's PromiseML 5/2

Wosie's Promise packs the highest TrackWiz rating in the race at 87.81 and matches the field's top career win percentage at 33% — this horse knows how to get to the winner's circle. Jockey Santo Sanjur takes over for trainer Antonio Duran, a combination worth watching. At 5/2 on the morning line, this isn't a value play, but the numbers justify making Wosie's Promise the cornerstone of your tickets in this allowance sprint.

place2TroglodyteML 9/2

Troglodyte heads into this race with a 75.90 rating and a 25% career win mark — solid credentials for a horse that's listed at 9/2 on the morning line and represents a bit of value relative to the top two. Jockey Alberto Burgos pairs with trainer Robert E. Dobbs, Jr., and the six-furlong distance on dirt is a format where horses with a clean turn of foot can show late.

show4Instilled ZipML 3/1

Instilled Zip profiles as a sneaky show play at 3/1 — a 73.78 rating and a 25% career win rate put this horse right in the thick of the competitive mid-tier. Marcelino Pedroza, Jr. is a capable rider, and trainer Anthony J. Granitz placing a 25% career winner at this distance suggests a horse ready to fire.

Race 3

7:12 PM EDT

Allowance · 6 fur · Dirt

I'm Game looks like the class of this seven-horse allowance sprint, but Small Hollow at 3/1 is no pushover — expect a two-horse race at the top with a pace battle that could open the door for Blazing Freedom.

win3I'm GameML 9/5

I'm Game comes in with the highest TrackWiz rating in the field at 88.83 and a 33% career win rate — one of every three starts ends in a winner's circle visit, which is elite at this level. The average speed figure of 55 is the best in the race, suggesting this horse has been running faster than anyone else in the field. Victor R. Carrasco gets the mount for trainer George R. Arnold II, and at 9/5, the market agrees this is the one to beat. Hard to argue with the numbers here.

place6Small HollowML 3/1

Small Hollow is the main danger at 3/1, posting an 82.38 TrackWiz rating and matching I'm Game's top average speed figure of 55. Gabriel Saez is a polished rider who can put a horse in position early on a six-furlong dirt track, and trainer Darrin Miller's 25% career win rate with this horse gives you confidence they're pointing here in good form.

show5Blazing FreedomML 5/2

Blazing Freedom at 5/2 offers a bit of middle-of-the-pack security — a 73.45 rating and a 25% career win mark make this horse a legitimate threat to hit the board if the top two press each other hard. Rodney A. Prescott handles the riding duties, and if there's a pace duel up front, Blazing Freedom could be picking up pieces in the stretch.

Our three free picks — Concho's Prayer in Race 1, Wosie's Promise in Race 2, and I'm Game in Race 3 — all land on the fast dirt early in the card. With TrackWiz ratings of 88.54, 87.81, and 88.83 respectively, these are among the highest-rated horses on the entire card, and none of them are prohibitive chalk. I'm Game opens as the 9/5 morning line favorite in Race 3, but Concho's Prayer at 2/1 in a one-mile claiming route and Wosie's Promise at 5/2 in a six-furlong allowance both represent solid fair-value plays rather than grinding your bankroll down on short prices.

A consistent, dry surface tends to reward horses with clean early position and reliable finishing kicks — keep that in mind as you watch the pace develop in Races 1 through 3. If the first two legs play out on the front end, pay attention to whether closers start making up ground in Race 3. That kind of pace bias read early in the card can pay dividends in the races that follow.

Send me tomorrow's free Horseshoe Indianapolis card before post time.

Free picks in your inbox each morning. No card required, unsubscribe anytime.

Full Card Analysis

Race 4

7:43 PM EDT

Claiming · 6 fur · Dirt

A wide-open nine-horse claiming sprint where the TrackWiz model sees a clear top horse in Unbridled Valor, but the morning line has spread the love — there's genuine value to be had in the exotics here.

win2Unbridled ValorML 4/1

Unbridled Valor leads this field with an 85.62 TrackWiz rating and posts the highest average speed figure in the race at 54, matching several rivals but doing it more consistently according to our model. At 4/1 on the morning line, Hannah Leahey and trainer Israel J. Garcia are getting a fair price on what looks like the standout. A 10% career win rate isn't eye-popping, but the class of the speed figures makes this the play.

place4Mega WichML 8/1

Mega Wich is a sneaky value play at 8/1 — the 78.01 TrackWiz rating is second in the field and the horse carries the top average speed figure in the race at 55. Trainer Randy L. Klopp clearly has this horse fit, and Micah Meeks can be aggressive early in short sprints. If Unbridled Valor hits any trouble, Mega Wich is the horse most likely to capitalize.

show3Pray for VictoryML 9/2

Pray for Victory at 9/2 fills out the show spot nicely — a 70.64 rating and a 12% career win rate keep this horse relevant in a nine-horse field where chaos can happen. Alexander Crispin is a capable pilot, and trainer Kenia Hernandez also runs Boss Justice in this race, giving the barn two shots. Pray for Victory is the more likely board-hitter of the two.

Race 5

8:14 PM EDT

Starter Optional Claiming · 1 1/16 mi · Turf

Moving to the turf for a 1 1/16-mile Starter Optional Claiming — the surface switch is key here, and Couldyoubeloved and Hidden Recipe look like the class of a field where several horses are facing unfamiliar conditions.

win3CouldyoubelovedML 5/2

Couldyoubeloved tops the TrackWiz ratings at 87.81 in what is a contested turf field, with a 28% career win rate that speaks to a horse who fires with regularity. Trainer Joe Sharp is known for placing horses in spots where they can win, and Marcelino Pedroza, Jr. handles the mount — a rider who's comfortable on the turf at route distances. At 5/2 on the morning line, this is the right price for the top-rated horse.

place9Hidden RecipeML 7/2

Hidden Recipe carries the highest career win rate in the field at 40% — that number stands out in a race card full of teenagers and twenties. Orlando Mojica gets the call, and the 82.22 TrackWiz rating puts this horse right behind our top pick. At 7/2, there's real place value here for a horse that wins nearly half the time it runs.

show10Annie ExpressML 4/1

Annie Express at 4/1 brings a 27% career win rate and a 63.57 rating — third in the TrackWiz standings for this race. Trainer Chaz Rechy puts Joseph D. Ramos up, and a horse going 1 1/16 miles on turf with that kind of win history is one worth having in your exotics. If the top two press each other in the stretch, Annie Express is positioned to pick up a check.

Race 6

8:45 PM EDT

Maiden Special Weight · 6 fur · Dirt

Maiden Special Weight sprints are always tricky, but this one has a legitimate standout — Up N Up's 82.11 TrackWiz rating is a full six points clear of the next horse, and at 2/1, the morning line reflects confidence from the connections.

win7Up N UpML 2/1

Up N Up leads all maidens in this field with an 82.11 TrackWiz rating and comes in at 2/1 — the morning line favorite for trainer Michael E. Lauer and jockey Danny Sheehy. The six-furlong dirt sprint is a forgiving format for a first-out or early-career type, and the model sees a clear class edge here. In a race where everyone is still looking for their first win, having the best number and top connections matters most.

place1Favorite StarML 5/1

Favorite Star posts a 75.81 rating — second in the field — and trainer Scott D. Mullins saddles this horse with Micah Meeks aboard. At 5/1, Favorite Star represents solid place value in a field where the top end is thin enough that second-best might be all you need to hit the board. Mullins also runs Arboretum in this race, but our analysis likes Favorite Star as the stable's better bet.

show5MikestrumpcardML 6/1

Mikestrumpcard at 6/1 slots in nicely as a show play with a 67.28 rating — third in the field among the MSW maidens. Trainer John Haran sends out two horses in this race including Crazy Legs Mike at 3/1, but it's Mikestrumpcard's higher TrackWiz number that earns the spot on our ticket. Santo Sanjur handles the riding duties and knows this track well.

Race 7

9:16 PM EDT

Allowance · 1 mi · Turf

Jailhouse Justice looks like a heavy-duty favorite in the making for this one-mile turf allowance — a 9/5 morning line backed by the top TrackWiz rating in the field, though Tail Gunner and a pair of deeper closers could make this a real stretch battle.

win6Jailhouse JusticeML 9/5

Jailhouse Justice is the clear top pick here with an 88.83 TrackWiz rating — matching the highest mark on today's entire card — and an average speed figure of 55 that leads this field outright. A 19% career win rate is steady, and trainer Anthony J. Granitz also runs Tail Gunner in this race, suggesting a barn in good form. Alex Achard gets the call, and on one-mile turf, a horse with this kind of speed advantage and rating edge is hard to oppose.

place4Tail GunnerML 4/1

Tail Gunner, also from the Granitz barn, brings a 70.55 rating and a 22% career win rate to back up his stablemate. Marcelino Pedroza, Jr. is a strong rider for this distance and surface, and the pace scenario could set up perfectly if Jailhouse Justice goes to the front — Tail Gunner can follow cover and strike late. At 4/1 on the morning line, the place price should be reasonable.

show2Henry the HankML 10/1

Henry the Hank is worth a long look at 10/1 — a 67.12 TrackWiz rating and a 20% career win mark put this horse competitive against a field where several runners rate much lower. Trainer Jonathan Nance and jockey Mitchell Murrill team up, and if the pace scenario gets messy or the top two don't fire, Henry the Hank has the quiet credentials to grab a piece.

Race 8

9:47 PM EDT

Maiden Special Weight · 1 mi · Turf

A deep ten-horse Maiden Special Weight on turf at a mile, featuring several blue-chip trainers — Brad Cox has two runners, Riley Mott has two, and the ratings are compressed enough that this race is genuinely hard to call.

win10Start the DiscoML 9/5

Start the Disco is our top pick despite not owning the highest rating in the field — a 58.67 TrackWiz score and an average speed figure of 55 (tied for best) puts this Riley Mott trainee in a strong position. Mott is a trainer who routinely produces sharp first-out and early-career turf runners, and Victor R. Carrasco in the irons on a one-mile maiden turf route is a winning combination. At 9/5 on the morning line, the market agrees.

place3ConiferML 3/1

Conifer is trained by Brad H. Cox — one of the top conditioners in the country — and that alone warrants respect in any maiden field. A 56.67 rating and a 3/1 morning line suggest the connections like their chances, even without a published average speed figure to lean on. Marcelino Pedroza, Jr. takes the mount, and a Cox-Pedroza team in a turf maiden is always a dangerous combination worth including on your place tickets.

show4Modern LegacyML 7/2

Modern Legacy at 7/2 is trained by Eoin G. Harty, another conditioner with a strong track record developing turf horses from the ground up. The 55.83 rating and an average speed figure of 54 give this horse a legitimate platform to compete, and Emmanuel Esquivel is a capable handler in these maiden conditions. In a race this competitive, Modern Legacy's pedigree-friendly trainer pedigree makes the show spot a reasonable hedge.

Race 9

10:15 PM EDT

Maiden · 300 yd · Dirt

The card closes with a 300-yard dirt maiden sprint — a completely different breed of racing that's decided in a blink, and our TrackWiz model identifies a standout at a generous morning line price in a wide-open twelve-horse field.

win5Monday TemptationsML 12/1

Monday Temptations holds the highest TrackWiz rating in this field at 68.34 — a clear model-edge in a race where most runners are below 55. Trainer Tim Eggleston saddles this horse alongside stablemate Lone Star Kisser, suggesting the barn has multiple live shots in the 300-yard maiden. At 12/1 on the morning line, Monday Temptations represents genuine overlay value for a horse our model rates as the top contender. In a race this short, gate speed and early quickness are everything — back the rating.

place12Blue Collar CowboyML 6/1

Blue Collar Cowboy at 6/1 posts a 60.80 TrackWiz rating — second best in this twelve-horse field — and trainer Karin Yike also runs Kats Bad Habit in the race, providing a two-pronged attack. Francisco Quintero rides both Karin Yike horses, and if anyone in this barn fires, Blue Collar Cowboy is the more likely board-hitter based on the numbers. Short sprints like this reward horses who break clean, and this one profiles to do exactly that.

show9Heza ClownML 7/2

Heza Clown is the morning line's second choice at 7/2 with a 55.83 rating and trainer Natasha Perez sending out Diego Villamil Bocanegra — a combination flying a bit under the radar. In a 300-yard blast where fractions are measured in fractions of seconds, the crowd often gravitates to name recognition, which could mean Heza Clown is slightly underbet. A solid rating and a fair price make this the reasonable show hedge on the finale.

Premium Content

Get the Full Card Analysis

Unlock expert picks for every race, detailed speed figures, trainer angles, and our SmartBet recommendations.

View Plans Sign In

Bottom line: today's Horseshoe Indianapolis card gives you legitimate plays from the jump, with I'm Game, Concho's Prayer, and Wosie's Promise forming a strong free-play foundation on the early dirt. The real depth — including two turf routes and a sprint finale with longshot appeal — is waiting in the full premium breakdown. Good luck out there, and as always, bet smart.

← All Horseshoe Indianapolis picks & predictions

You're reading 3 of 9 races free